Skip to content Skip to footer

Phishing: Can a bank refuse reimbursement on the basis of customer negligence?

Knowledge   >   Phishing: Can a bank refuse reimbursement on the basis of customer negligence?

The increasing digitalisation of banking services has been accompanied by a rise in the number and sophistication of cyber fraud schemes, particularly phishing attacks.

In this context, one of the most relevant questions is who should bear the loss when a customer, having been deceived by third parties, inadvertently enables them to access their bank account and carry out unauthorised transactions.

This was precisely the issue addressed by the Court of Justice of the European Union (CJEU) in its judgment of 15 October 2026, delivered in Case C-70/25. The Court clarified that any gross negligence on the part of the customer does not entitle a payment service provider to refuse immediate reimbursement of an unauthorised payment transaction.

The case originated from a fraud incident in Poland. A bank customer had listed an item for sale on an online platform and was subsequently contacted by someone claiming to be interested in purchasing it. The alleged buyer sent her a fraudulent link, apparently intended to confirm the sale.

After clicking on the link, the customer was redirected to a webpage reproducing the appearance of her bank’s website, where she entered her online banking credentials and subsequently provided a confirmation code received by SMS. Using these details, a third party managed to transfer PLN 3,000 (approximately EUR 705) from her account.

Although she reported the fraud to the bank the following day, the bank refused to reimburse her, arguing that she had acted with gross negligence by failing to adequately protect her security credentials.

When called upon to rule on the matter, the CJEU held that the payer’s gross negligence does not constitute grounds for setting aside the obligation of immediate reimbursement.

The Court therefore distinguished between two separate stages: the bank must immediately reimburse the unauthorised payment transaction and cannot rely on the customer’s gross negligence to refuse reimbursement, without prejudice to its right to subsequently seek repayment of the amounts concerned if it can establish that such gross negligence occurred.

It should be recalled that, under the Directive, is for the payment service provider to prove that the customer acted fraudulently or with gross negligence. Merely demonstrating that the customer’s payment credentials were used to execute the transaction is not sufficient.

The only exception to the obligation of immediate reimbursement arises where the payment service provider has reasonable grounds to suspect fraud committed by the payer. Those grounds must be communicated in writing to the competent national authority.

In Portugal, the legal framework governing unauthorised payment transactions is set out in the Legal Framework for Payment Services and Electronic Money, which transposes Directive (EU) 2015/2366 of 25 November 2015.

Although it significantly strengthens consumer protection, the approach adopted by the CJEU is not without practical difficulties.

Indeed, in cases involving manifest gross negligence, immediate reimbursement may, in practice, amount merely to an advance payment of the sum in question, since the bank may subsequently seek its recovery, provided that it establishes the conditions for the customer’s liability.

The customer may therefore initially receive the funds while remaining exposed to the possibility of having to repay them.

At the same time, the payment service provider is also exposed to the risk of being unable to effectively recover the amounts reimbursed.

In conclusion, this judgment does not exclude the possibility of the customer being held liable for acting with gross negligence, nor does it establish the absolute liability of banking institutions. Rather, it clarifies that the obligation of immediate reimbursement cannot be made conditional upon a prior assessment of the customer’s liability, which may only be determined at a later stage (potentially giving rise to further litigation and costs for both parties).

.

Lisbon-Porto-Algarve

About Us

We are a full service company that has been guided by solid and sustained growth. We are focused on the success of our Clients in the various jurisdictions where we operate.

Contact us
+351 214 046 850
+351 218 041 673
crs@crs-advogados.com
Subscribe newsletter

Don’t miss the latest news, follow
our work and useful information.

ยฉ 2026 – Cruz, Roque, Semiรฃo e Associados โ€“ Sociedade de Advogados, SP, RL

Need legal assistance? Let's talk.